Political Science Important Questions And Answers B.A - 2 Semester (NEP) English Medium

byChandigarh Education B.A (NEP) -

Political Science Important Questions And Answers B.A - 2 Semester (NEP)English Medium



Question  :- Government of India act 1935

Answer 

The Government of India Act, 1935 was a key legislative act passed by the British Parliament, and it marked a significant step in the constitutional development of India under British rule. It was the last and most comprehensive Act passed before India gained independence in 1947.

🔑 Key Features of the Government of India Act, 1935

  1. Abolition of Dyarchy at Provincial Level:

    • The system of dyarchy (dual government) introduced by the Government of India Act, 1919 was abolished in provinces.

    • Provinces were granted autonomy, and provincial ministers were responsible to the elected legislatures.

  2. Introduction of Dyarchy at the Centre:

    • While dyarchy was removed from the provinces, it was introduced at the central government level.

    • The British retained control over important matters like defense, external affairs, and ecclesiastical affairs.

  3. Federal Structure:

    • The Act proposed an All-India Federation consisting of British Indian provinces and princely states.

    • The federation was never implemented as most princely states refused to join.

  4. Division of Powers:

    • Powers were divided between the Centre and Provinces into three lists: Federal, Provincial, and Concurrent.

  5. Bicameral Legislature at Centre:

    • A bicameral legislature was established: Council of States (upper house) and Federal Assembly (lower house).

  6. Extension of Franchise:

    • The right to vote was extended, but still based on property, income, or education, not universal suffrage.

    • About 10% of the population could vote.

  7. Establishment of Federal Court:

    • A Federal Court of India was established in 1937.

  8. Separate Electorates:

    • Continued the policy of separate electorates for minorities (Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, etc.), which deepened communal divisions.

  9. Reserve Bank of India:

    • Provided for the establishment of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in 1935, which began operations in 1935.

📜 Significance

  • It was the most extensive Act made by the British to govern India.

  • Though many provisions were not fully implemented, it laid the groundwork for India's constitutional structure.

  • The Indian Constitution of 1950 borrowed many elements from this Act, like the federal system and division of powers.




Question :- Government of India act 1853

Answer

The Government of India Act, 1853 was a significant piece of British legislation that marked a transitional phase in the administration of India. It was the last act passed by the British Parliament before the revolt of 1857 and the subsequent end of the East India Company's rule.

🔑 Key Features of the Government of India Act, 1853

  1. Separation of Legislative and Executive Functions:

    • For the first time, the legislative and executive functions of the Governor-General’s Council were separated.

    • A new Legislative Council was created to make laws, which included additional non-official members.

  2. Expansion of the Governor-General’s Council:

    • The number of members was increased; six new legislative members were added.

    • This council functioned as a miniature parliament for India.

  3. Open Competitive Examination for Civil Services:

    • The Act introduced the principle of open competition for recruitment to the Indian Civil Services (ICS).

    • This ended the earlier practice of nominations and was intended to make the service merit-based.

    • However, in practice, this system remained largely inaccessible to Indians for many years.

  4. No Fixed Tenure for the Company:

    • The Act did not renew the East India Company’s charter for any fixed period, unlike earlier acts.

    • It declared that the Company would hold India at the pleasure of the British Crown, indicating a shift towards tighter Crown control.

  5. Provision for Indian Representation:

    • For the first time, Indians could be appointed to the Legislative Council, although this was rarely done.

📜 Significance

  • This Act marked the beginning of parliamentary control over Indian affairs through the establishment of a separate legislative body.

  • It reflected growing concerns in Britain over the administration of India, and a recognition that governance needed reform.

  • It laid the groundwork for later reforms and was a precursor to the transfer of power to the British Crown after 1858.




Question :- Write a note on founding principle of Indian constitution

Answer

🧭 Founding Principles of the Indian Constitution – A Brief Note

The Indian Constitution, adopted on 26th January 1950, is founded on a set of core principles that reflect the aspirations of the Indian freedom struggle and the vision of its makers. These principles ensure justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity for all citizens, and form the philosophical and moral foundation of the nation.

🔑 Key Founding Principles

  1. Sovereignty

    • India is a sovereign nation, free to make its own laws and policies without external interference.

    • This reflects the country's complete independence and control over internal and external matters.

  2. Democracy

    • India follows a parliamentary democratic system, where power is derived from the people through universal adult franchise.

    • Citizens have the right to vote, elect representatives, and participate in governance.

  3. Secularism

    • The Constitution ensures freedom of religion and equal treatment of all religions by the State.

    • The State has no official religion and maintains neutrality in religious matters.

  4. Socialism

    • The Constitution seeks to promote social and economic equality.

    • It aims to reduce income disparities and ensure that wealth is not concentrated in a few hands.

  5. Justice (Social, Economic, and Political)

    • The Constitution guarantees justice in all spheres to ensure a fair and equitable society.

    • This is reflected in Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy.

  6. Liberty

    • The Constitution guarantees liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith, and worship.

    • Fundamental Rights protect individual freedoms essential to personal development.

  7. Equality

    • All citizens are equal before the law and have equal protection under the law.

    • Discrimination based on religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth is prohibited.

  8. Fraternity

    • Promotes a sense of brotherhood and unity among citizens, ensuring the dignity of the individual and unity of the nation.

    • Helps maintain harmony in India’s diverse society.

📜 Conclusion

These founding principles are enshrined in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution and are reflected throughout its provisions. They form the ideological backbone of the Indian republic and continue to guide its democratic journey.




Question :- Critically analyse the preamble of the Indian constitution

Answer 

🧭 Critical Analysis of the Preamble of the Indian Constitution

The Preamble to the Indian Constitution is often described as the soul and essence of the Constitution. It outlines the fundamental values and guiding principles upon which the Constitution is based. Though not legally enforceable, it plays a critical role in the interpretation of constitutional provisions and reflects the vision of the framers of the Constitution.

📝 Text of the Preamble (as amended in 1976)

“We, the People of India, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic and to secure to all its citizens:
Justice, social, economic and political;
Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship;
Equality of status and of opportunity;
and to promote among them all
Fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation;
In our Constituent Assembly, this 26th day of November, 1949, do hereby adopt, enact and give to ourselves this Constitution.”

✅ Strengths and Contributions of the Preamble

  1. Source of Authority – “We, the People”

    • Emphasizes popular sovereignty, meaning the Constitution derives its legitimacy from the people, not any monarch or colonial power.

  2. Clear Declaration of Ideals

    • Encapsulates the philosophy of the Constitution and the goals of the Indian Republic.

    • The ideals of justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity are rooted in both Western liberalism and Indian nationalist movements.

  3. Reflects India's Aspirational Character

    • It lays out a vision of an ideal society, pushing the State to work toward socioeconomic transformation, beyond just political independence.

  4. Guidance in Constitutional Interpretation

    • The Supreme Court has referred to the Preamble as a key to understanding the Constitution's spirit (e.g., in Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, 1973).

  5. Amendable but Not Superseded

    • The 42nd Amendment (1976) added the words "Socialist" and "Secular", reflecting evolving aspirations without altering the basic structure.

⚠️ Criticisms and Limitations of the Preamble

  1. Not Legally Enforceable

    • Unlike Fundamental Rights, the Preamble cannot be enforced in a court of law.

    • It is declaratory, not mandatory.

  2. Ambiguity in Terminology

    • Terms like "Socialist" or "Secular" have been interpreted differently over time, leading to political and judicial controversies.

    • Critics argue that these terms may reflect a particular ideological tilt, especially with their insertion during the Emergency.

  3. Addition Through 42nd Amendment

    • The inclusion of “Socialist” and “Secular” during the Emergency in 1976 raised questions about political motivations behind constitutional changes.

    • Some jurists and scholars argue that these changes were made without adequate public consultation.

  4. Overambitious Goals

    • The Preamble’s promise of justice, equality, and fraternity remains partially unfulfilled, especially for marginalized groups.

    • Critics question whether these lofty ideals match ground realities in areas like poverty, caste discrimination, and gender inequality.

⚖️ Judicial Viewpoint

  • In Kesavananda Bharati Case (1973): The Supreme Court held that the Preamble is part of the Constitution and reflects its basic structure, which cannot be destroyed by amendments.

  • In Berubari Union Case (1960): Earlier, the Court held that the Preamble is not enforceable, but this view was later reconsidered.

🧩 Conclusion

The Preamble of the Indian Constitution is a visionary statement that reflects the hopes and dreams of a newly independent nation. It acts as a moral compass and a guiding star for constitutional interpretation. While not free from criticism, especially in terms of enforceability and ideological clarity, its symbolic and philosophical value is immense. It continues to be a beacon of democratic values in a diverse and evolving society like India.




Question :- Write a note on preamble of the Indian constitution

Answer

🧭 Note on the Preamble of the Indian Constitution

The Preamble to the Indian Constitution serves as an introductory statement that outlines the core values, objectives, and philosophy on which the Constitution is based. It reflects the aspirations and ideals of the people of India and provides a guiding light for interpreting the Constitution.

📜 Text of the Preamble (Post 42nd Amendment, 1976)

“We, the People of India, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic Republic and to secure to all its citizens:
Justice, social, economic and political;
Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship;
Equality of status and of opportunity;
and to promote among them all
Fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation…”

🔑 Key Elements of the Preamble

  1. We, the People of India

    • Highlights that the power and authority of the Constitution come from the people themselves—popular sovereignty.

  2. Sovereign

    • India is independent in both internal and external affairs.

  3. Socialist

    • Promotes social and economic equality, aiming for a more just distribution of wealth and resources.

  4. Secular

    • Ensures freedom of religion and equal treatment of all religions by the State.

  5. Democratic

    • India has a parliamentary democracy, where leaders are elected by the people.

  6. Republic

    • The head of the State is elected, not a hereditary monarch.

  7. Justice

    • Social, economic, and political justice for all citizens.

  8. Liberty

    • Guarantees freedom of thought, expression, belief, faith, and worship.

  9. Equality

    • Ensures equal opportunity and status for all.

  10. Fraternity

  • Promotes brotherhood, unity, and respect for the dignity of every individual.

⚖️ Legal Status

  • The Preamble is not legally enforceable, but it is an integral part of the Constitution.

  • The Supreme Court has held (in the Kesavananda Bharati case, 1973) that the Preamble reflects the basic structure of the Constitution and cannot be amended to alter its fundamental character.

🧩 Conclusion

The Preamble of the Indian Constitution is a powerful statement of values and vision, guiding both governance and constitutional interpretation. It embodies the spirit of the Constitution and serves as a moral compass for Indian democracy.




Question :- Discuss the nature and importance of fundamental rights

Answer 

📘 Nature and Importance of Fundamental Rights in the Indian Constitution

🔍 Nature of Fundamental Rights

Fundamental Rights are a set of legal guarantees provided under Part III (Articles 12 to 35) of the Indian Constitution. They are essential for the overall development of individuals and for maintaining a just, democratic, and equitable society.

Key features of their nature:

  1. Justiciable in Nature

    • They are legally enforceable. If violated, individuals can directly approach the Supreme Court (Article 32) or High Courts (Article 226) for redress.

  2. Limitations on State Power

    • They act as a check on arbitrary power of the State by limiting its actions, ensuring governance stays within constitutional bounds.

  3. Available Against the State (Mostly)

    • Fundamental Rights are mainly enforceable against the State, though some rights (like protection from untouchability or human trafficking) can apply to private individuals too.

  4. Subject to Reasonable Restrictions

    • Rights are not absolute; the State can impose reasonable restrictions on grounds like public order, morality, and national security.

  5. Fundamental but Not Absolute

    • The rights must balance individual liberty with the collective interest of society.

  6. Evolving and Expansive

    • Through judicial interpretation (e.g., Right to Privacy, Right to a Clean Environment), the scope of rights has expanded over time.

⭐ Importance of Fundamental Rights

  1. Safeguard Individual Liberty

    • They protect citizens from arbitrary actions of the State and guarantee civil liberties like freedom of speech, movement, religion, and more.

  2. Promote Equality

    • Rights like Right to Equality (Article 14–18) ensure there is no discrimination based on caste, gender, religion, or race.

  3. Support Democracy

    • Fundamental Rights are essential for democratic functioning, ensuring freedom of expression, association, and participation in public life.

  4. Empowerment of Citizens

    • Marginalized and disadvantaged groups are empowered through protections such as the Abolition of Untouchability (Article 17) and Protection of Cultural and Educational Rights (Articles 29–30).

  5. Foundation for Rule of Law

    • These rights uphold the rule of law, ensuring all citizens and institutions are subject to the Constitution.

  6. Facilitate Social Justice

    • Combined with Directive Principles of State Policy, they help achieve social and economic justice, key to the vision of a welfare state.

⚖️ Judicial Protection

  • Article 32: Called the “heart and soul” of the Constitution by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, it gives individuals the right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights.

  • The courts have used Public Interest Litigation (PIL) and judicial activism to make rights more accessible.

🧩 Conclusion

Fundamental Rights are the cornerstone of Indian democracy. They not only guarantee individual freedom and dignity but also ensure equality and justice, making them indispensable for the functioning of a free and fair society. Their protection and proper implementation are vital for the progressive and inclusive growth of the nation.




Question :- Discuss the article 14 to 18 right to equality and right to freedom article 19 to 22 in detail

Answer 

These articles are part of Part III of the Indian Constitution, which deals with Fundamental Rights. They ensure individual liberty, dignity, and protection from arbitrary state actions.

🇮🇳 I. Articles 14 to 18 – Right to Equality

📜 Article 14 – Equality before Law and Equal Protection of Laws

  • Guarantees that all persons are equal before the law and will get equal protection under the law.

  • "Equality before law" = No special privileges; everyone is subject to the law.

  • "Equal protection of laws" = Similar treatment under similar circumstances.

  • Applies to both citizens and non-citizens.

  • Allows reasonable classification, but not arbitrary discrimination.

🧑‍⚖️ Example: Striking down of Section 377 (Navtej Singh Johar case, 2018) as discriminatory under Article 14.

📜 Article 15 – Prohibition of Discrimination

  • Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.

  • Covers access to public spaces like shops, wells, tanks, and roads.

  • Allows special provisions for women, children, and socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs), including Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).

👩‍🎓 Example: Reservation of seats for women in educational institutions or jobs.

📜 Article 16 – Equality of Opportunity in Public Employment

  • Guarantees equal opportunity in public jobs or offices.

  • Prohibits discrimination in employment under the State.

  • Permits reservation for backward classes, SCs, STs, and economically weaker sections (EWS).

🧑‍💼 Example: Reservation in government jobs for SC/ST candidates.

📜 Article 17 – Abolition of Untouchability

  • Declares untouchability illegal and its practice in any form a punishable offense.

  • Aimed at ending caste-based social exclusion.

📚 Example: Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 gives effect to this article.

📜 Article 18 – Abolition of Titles

  • Prohibits the State from conferring titles (except military or academic distinctions).

  • Indian citizens cannot accept titles from foreign States.

  • Aimed at promoting a classless and egalitarian society.

❌ Example: British titles like "Sir" or "Rai Bahadur" are abolished.

🗽 II. Articles 19 to 22 – Right to Freedom

📜 Article 19 – Protection of Six Freedoms

Available only to citizens, Article 19 guarantees:

  1. Freedom of speech and expression

  2. Freedom to assemble peacefully

  3. Freedom to form associations or unions

  4. Freedom to move freely throughout the territory of India

  5. Freedom to reside and settle in any part of India

  6. Freedom to practice any profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or business

✅ Reasonable Restrictions: Imposed in the interests of sovereignty, public order, morality, or national security.

🗣️ Example: Bans on hate speech under freedom of speech.

📜 Article 20 – Protection in Respect of Conviction for Offences

Protects individuals in criminal law matters:

  1. No ex-post facto law – Can’t be punished for an act that was not a crime when committed.

  2. No double jeopardy – Can’t be tried twice for the same offence.

  3. No self-incrimination – Cannot be forced to be a witness against oneself.

⚖️ Example: Right used in criminal trials and investigations (e.g., refusal to give confession).

📜 Article 21 – Protection of Life and Personal Liberty

  • No person shall be deprived of life or liberty except according to procedure established by law.

  • This article has been widely interpreted by the judiciary to include:

    • Right to privacy

    • Right to clean environment

    • Right to legal aid

    • Right to education (till age 14)

    • Right to die with dignity (passive euthanasia)

👨‍⚖️ Example: Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India – expanded scope of personal liberty.

📜 Article 21A – Right to Education

  • Introduced by the 86th Amendment Act, 2002.

  • Makes free and compulsory education a right for all children aged 6 to 14 years.

📚 Example: Mid-day meal schemes and school enrolment drives.

📜 Article 22 – Protection Against Arrest and Detention

Provides safeguards in two scenarios:

  1. In ordinary criminal cases:

    • Right to be informed of grounds of arrest.

    • Right to consult a lawyer.

    • Right to be presented before a magistrate within 24 hours.

  2. In preventive detention cases:

    • Allows detention for 3 months without trial, but must be reviewed by an advisory board.

    • Certain rights are limited (e.g., no right to a lawyer or to be informed of all charges).

🛑 Example: Laws like National Security Act (NSA) fall under preventive detention.

✅ Conclusion

Articles 14 to 18 ensure equality, dismantle discriminatory practices, and uphold a just society. Articles 19 to 22 guarantee personal freedoms and protection from state overreach. Together, these articles form the bedrock of Indian democracy, balancing individual liberty with public interest.




Question :- Write a detailed note on fundamental right given in the Indian constitution

Answer 

📘 Detailed Note on Fundamental Rights in the Indian Constitution

The Fundamental Rights, enshrined in Part III (Articles 12 to 35) of the Indian Constitution, are essential human freedoms that every citizen of India is entitled to. These rights aim to promote individual dignity, social justice, and democratic governance, ensuring that the government operates within constitutional limits.

🧭 Key Features of Fundamental Rights

  1. Justiciable:

    • Citizens can directly approach the Supreme Court (Article 32) or High Courts (Article 226) to enforce their Fundamental Rights.

  2. Available Against State (and Sometimes Private Entities):

    • Mostly enforceable against the State, but some rights (like abolition of untouchability) also apply to private individuals.

  3. Not Absolute:

    • Rights are subject to reasonable restrictions to maintain public order, morality, and national security.

  4. Can Be Suspended During Emergency:

    • Except for Articles 20 and 21, rights can be suspended during a national emergency under Article 352.

  5. Subject to Constitutional Amendments:

    • Rights can be amended, but not to the extent of destroying the “basic structure” of the Constitution (as per Kesavananda Bharati case, 1973).

📜 List of Fundamental Rights (Articles 12 to 35)

1️⃣ Right to Equality (Articles 14–18)

  • Article 14 – Equality before law and equal protection of laws

  • Article 15 – Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth

  • Article 16 – Equality of opportunity in matters of public employment

  • Article 17 – Abolition of untouchability

  • Article 18 – Abolition of titles

Objective: To ensure equal treatment, eliminate caste and social discrimination, and uphold merit-based opportunities.

2️⃣ Right to Freedom (Articles 19–22)

  • Article 19 – Six basic freedoms (speech, assembly, association, movement, residence, profession)

  • Article 20 – Protection in respect of conviction for offences (no ex-post facto law, double jeopardy, self-incrimination)

  • Article 21 – Protection of life and personal liberty (expanded to include right to privacy, clean environment, health, education, etc.)

  • Article 21A – Right to free and compulsory education for children aged 6–14

  • Article 22 – Protection against arbitrary arrest and preventive detention

Objective: To protect individual liberty, allow freedom of expression, and provide safeguards against misuse of state power.

3️⃣ Right against Exploitation (Articles 23–24)

  • Article 23 – Prohibition of human trafficking and forced labor

  • Article 24 – Prohibition of child labor in hazardous employment (under age 14)

Objective: To eliminate exploitation, forced labor, and protect human dignity, especially for vulnerable groups.

4️⃣ Right to Freedom of Religion (Articles 25–28)

  • Article 25 – Freedom of conscience and right to freely profess, practice, and propagate religion

  • Article 26 – Freedom to manage religious affairs

  • Article 27 – Freedom from paying taxes for the promotion of any religion

  • Article 28 – Freedom from religious instruction in state-run educational institutions

Objective: To maintain secularism and ensure religious freedom in a diverse society.

5️⃣ Cultural and Educational Rights (Articles 29–30)

  • Article 29 – Protection of interests of minorities in conserving their culture, language, or script

  • Article 30 – Right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions

Objective: To preserve India’s cultural diversity and protect minority rights.

6️⃣ Right to Constitutional Remedies (Article 32)

  • Article 32 – Right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights (called the "heart and soul" of the Constitution by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar)

  • Provides writs:

    • Habeas Corpus – Produce the body

    • Mandamus – We command

    • Prohibition – Forbids lower court

    • Certiorari – To be informed

    • Quo Warranto – By what authority

Objective: To provide effective enforcement of all Fundamental Rights.

⚖️ Judicial Interpretation and Expansion

Indian courts, especially the Supreme Court, have played a crucial role in expanding the scope of Fundamental Rights. For example:

  • Right to Privacy declared a Fundamental Right under Article 21 in 2017 (Puttaswamy case).

  • Right to a Clean Environment, Right to Shelter, and Right to Legal Aid have been recognized through judicial interpretation.

🧩 Conclusion

Fundamental Rights form the foundation of Indian democracy. They ensure the protection of individual liberty, maintain the rule of law, and promote social and economic justice. Their effective implementation is vital for achieving the goals of the Preamble – justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity.




Question :- Critically evaluate the directive principle of State policy in India

Answer 

📘 Critical Evaluation of the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) in India

The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs) are enshrined in Part IV (Articles 36 to 51) of the Indian Constitution. Inspired largely by the Irish Constitution, these principles aim to establish a just and egalitarian society by guiding the State in policymaking and governance.

📜 Nature and Objectives of DPSPs

  • Non-justiciable: DPSPs are not legally enforceable in courts, unlike Fundamental Rights.

  • Moral and Political Obligations: They serve as guiding principles for the State to promote social and economic democracy.

  • Goal: Achieve the objectives of the Preamble – Justice, Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity – and establish a welfare state.

🧭 Classification of DPSPs

  1. Socialistic Principles (Articles 38–43, 47):

    • Aim for economic equality, livelihood, equal pay, and healthcare.

    • Example: Article 39 – Equal pay for equal work, Article 41 – Right to work.

  2. Gandhian Principles (Articles 40, 43B, 46–48):

    • Based on Mahatma Gandhi’s ideals like village panchayats, cottage industries, and animal husbandry.

    • Example: Article 40 – Organization of village panchayats.

  3. Liberal-Intellectual Principles (Articles 44, 45, 48A, 50, 51):

    • Reflect the modern liberal philosophy like Uniform Civil Code, education, separation of judiciary, and environmental protection.

    • Example: Article 44 – Uniform Civil Code; Article 48A – Protection of environment.

✅ Achievements and Importance of DPSPs

  1. Guiding Social Legislation:

    • DPSPs have influenced laws like:

      • Abolition of Zamindari System

      • Equal Remuneration Act (1976)

      • Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), 2005

  2. Expansion of Fundamental Rights:

    • Many Directive Principles have been elevated to justiciable status through constitutional amendments and judicial interpretations.

    • Example: Right to Education (Article 21A) was moved from DPSP (Article 45) to Fundamental Rights.

  3. Judicial Support:

    • Courts now interpret Fundamental Rights in harmony with DPSPs.

    • Minerva Mills case (1980): SC held that Fundamental Rights and DPSPs are complementary, not contradictory.

  4. Welfare State Framework:

    • Provides a moral direction to the government to pursue social and economic justice.

❌ Criticisms of DPSPs

  1. Non-Enforceability:

    • Their lack of legal enforceability makes them weak in implementation, especially when they clash with political or economic interests.

  2. Vague and Idealistic:

    • Some principles are broad and undefined (e.g., "living wage", "adequate means of livelihood"), making them difficult to implement or measure.

  3. Conflict with Fundamental Rights:

    • Historically, some DPSPs (like land reforms under Article 39) have conflicted with Fundamental Rights (especially Article 19 and 31), leading to legal battles.

  4. Selective Implementation:

    • Governments have cherry-picked certain DPSPs (like cooperative societies or panchayats) while ignoring others (like Uniform Civil Code).

⚖️ Judicial Evolution and Balancing

Case Verdict
Champakam Dorairajan (1951) Fundamental Rights prevail over DPSPs.
Kesavananda Bharati (1973) DPSPs are part of the basic structure and must be harmonized with FRs.
Minerva Mills (1980) Balance between Fundamental Rights and DPSPs is essential.
Unni Krishnan (1993) Right to education was read into Article 21 (now Article 21A).

🧩 Conclusion

The Directive Principles of State Policy reflect the aspirations of a welfare state and bridge the gap between law and justice. Though non-justiciable, they have shaped numerous social and economic reforms in India. For them to be truly effective, political will, public pressure, and judicial activism must ensure their progressive realization, making India not just a political democracy but also a social and economic one.




Question :- Discuss the appointment power and function and position of Indian President

Answer

🇮🇳 President of India – Appointment, Powers, Functions, and Position

The President of India is the constitutional head of the Indian Republic and the first citizen of the country. The office is established under Article 52 of the Indian Constitution.

🧾 1. Appointment of the President

📜 Election Process (Article 54 & 55)

  • Indirect Election:

    • Elected by an Electoral College consisting of:

      1. Elected members of both Houses of Parliament.

      2. Elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of all States and Union Territories with legislatures (e.g., Delhi, Puducherry).

  • Proportional Representation System:

    • Voting is done by single transferable vote and by secret ballot.

🕒 Tenure (Article 56):

  • 5 years; eligible for re-election any number of times.

📌 Qualifications (Article 58):

  • Indian citizen.

  • At least 35 years old.

  • Qualified to be elected as a member of the Lok Sabha.

  • Must not hold any office of profit under the Government.

⚖️ 2. Powers and Functions of the President

A. Executive Powers

  • All executive actions of the Union are taken in the President’s name (Article 77).

  • Appoints:

    • Prime Minister and other ministers (on PM’s advice)

    • Governors of States

    • Chief Justice and judges of Supreme Court and High Courts

    • Attorney General, CAG, Election Commissioners, UPSC members, Ambassadors, etc.

  • Supreme Commander of the Defence Forces of India.

B. Legislative Powers

  • Summons and prorogues Parliament, dissolves the Lok Sabha.

  • Addresses Parliament at the first session after general elections and the first session each year.

  • Gives assent to bills, including money bills and constitutional amendments.

  • Can withhold, give, or return (non-money bills) for reconsideration.

C. Financial Powers

  • Causes the Annual Budget to be laid before Parliament.

  • No money bill can be introduced without the President’s prior recommendation.

D. Judicial Powers

  • Can grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions of punishment (Article 72).

  • This includes cases under Union law, court-martial, or death sentence.

E. Emergency Powers

(Under Articles 352, 356, 360)

  • National Emergency

  • President’s Rule (State Emergency)

  • Financial Emergency

During emergencies, the President's powers become extraordinary, though still exercised on the advice of the Cabinet.

🪖 3. Position of the President in Indian Polity

⭐ Nominal Head / Constitutional Head

  • The President is a ceremonial executive, functioning on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers [Article 74(1)].

  • Real power lies with the Prime Minister and the Cabinet.

👥 Not a Rubber Stamp

  • Can send back non-money bills once for reconsideration.

  • Plays a key role during constitutional crises, hung parliaments, or dismissal of state governments.

⚖️ Guardian of the Constitution

  • Sworn to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution (Article 60).

  • Plays an important role during emergencies and ensures that constitutional machinery functions effectively.

🔍 Criticism and Debate

  • Critics often argue the President is a "rubber stamp" or figurehead, but:

    • In certain situations (e.g. hung Parliament, use of veto, imposition of President’s Rule), the President’s role becomes decisive.

  • Some advocate for a more active or elected President with real powers, but that would change the parliamentary system to a presidential system, which India does not follow.

🧩 Conclusion

The President of India is a symbol of national unity and a constitutional authority. While the role is largely ceremonial, the President is central to constitutional governance, especially in times of crisis. The office ensures continuity, checks and balances, and stability in the Indian democratic system.




Question :- Discuss the appointment power and function and position of prime minister Of India

Answer

🇮🇳 Prime Minister of India – Appointment, Powers, Functions, and Position

The Prime Minister of India (PM) is the chief executive of the country and holds a crucial position in India’s parliamentary system of government. The office of the Prime Minister is the most powerful in the Indian political system and plays a key role in shaping the direction of national governance.

🧾 1. Appointment of the Prime Minister

📜 Selection Process

  • The President of India formally appoints the Prime Minister.

  • In practice, the President appoints the leader of the majority party in the Lok Sabha (lower house of Parliament) or a coalition of parties that can command a majority in the Lok Sabha.

  • If no party has a clear majority (in a hung Parliament), the President may invite a pre-elected leader from the largest coalition or allow the largest party to prove its majority.

🕒 Tenure

  • The Prime Minister serves a 5-year term, but this term may be cut short if:

    • The Lok Sabha is dissolved.

    • The Prime Minister loses a vote of confidence or resignation.

  • The Prime Minister can be re-elected any number of times.

📌 Qualifications

  • The Prime Minister must be a Member of Parliament (MP) and should enjoy the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha.

  • There are no specific age or citizenship criteria for the office, other than those applicable to MPs (must be an Indian citizen and at least 25 years old).

⚖️ 2. Powers and Functions of the Prime Minister

A. Executive Powers

  • The Prime Minister is the head of the government and is responsible for executive decisions.

  • All executive actions of the Union government are carried out in the name of the President, but in practice, they are executed under the Prime Minister’s leadership.

  • The Prime Minister coordinates and supervises the working of the Council of Ministers.

B. Legislative Powers

  • The Prime Minister is responsible for making decisions regarding the introduction of bills in Parliament and can influence the legislative agenda.

  • The Prime Minister has the power to recommend the dissolution of the Lok Sabha, and the calling of Parliament sessions.

C. Decision-making Powers

  • The Prime Minister is the leader of the Cabinet and heads the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA), the most powerful decision-making body in the government.

  • The Prime Minister advises the President on matters of national importance, including decisions on the appointment of ministers, foreign policy, and major policy changes.

D. Role in Foreign Policy and National Security

  • The Prime Minister is a key figure in shaping the foreign policy of India, alongside the external affairs minister.

  • Plays a pivotal role in handling national security and defense, often as the Chairman of the National Security Council (NSC).

E. Leadership in Crisis

  • In times of political instability, a hung Parliament, or emergency situations, the Prime Minister plays a significant role in restoring order and ensuring the stability of the government.

  • In case of coalition governments, the Prime Minister must act as a mediator and keep the coalition united.

🌍 3. Position of the Prime Minister in Indian Polity

⭐ First Among Equals

  • The Prime Minister is often referred to as the “first among equals” within the Council of Ministers.

  • Although the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, the Prime Minister is the chief architect of policies and decisions.

🧑‍💼 Leader of the Majority Party

  • The Prime Minister is usually the leader of the largest party in the Lok Sabha, ensuring their party’s policies are implemented.

  • In a coalition government, the Prime Minister acts as the chief coordinator to ensure that various parties and factions within the coalition stay united and act according to the common agenda.

📋 Link Between the President and the Cabinet

  • The Prime Minister is the chief link between the President and the Council of Ministers.

  • Though the President is the constitutional head of the state, the real powers lie with the Prime Minister, who advises the President on all matters of state.

💥 4. Limitations on the Power of the Prime Minister

A. Collective Responsibility

  • The Prime Minister is bound by the principle of collective responsibility, which means that the entire Cabinet is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha for the actions of the government.

  • The Prime Minister cannot override the decision of the Cabinet, and if the Cabinet loses the confidence of the Lok Sabha, the entire government, including the Prime Minister, must resign.

B. Advisory Role to the President

  • While the Prime Minister holds the most executive powers, the President still plays a formal role in decision-making. For instance, the Prime Minister’s advice to the President on certain matters can be rejected if the President seeks a review, although this is rare in practice.

C. Dependence on Parliament and Public Opinion

  • The Prime Minister’s position is heavily dependent on support in Parliament and the public mandate.

  • A vote of no-confidence in the Lok Sabha can lead to the fall of the government and force the Prime Minister to resign.

🧩 5. Conclusion

The Prime Minister of India holds a position of immense power and influence. Although the role is defined by the parliamentary system of governance and works within the framework of constitutional provisions, the Prime Minister acts as the central figure of executive decision-making. Despite facing various limitations like collective responsibility and dependence on the Lok Sabha’s confidence, the Prime Minister has a dominant role in shaping the direction of policy, government functioning, and national development.




Question :- Evaluate the structure power and position of the supreme court of India

Answer :-

🇮🇳 Supreme Court of India – Structure, Powers, and Position

The Supreme Court of India (SCI), established by Article 124 of the Indian Constitution, is the highest judicial authority in the country. It holds the responsibility of safeguarding the Constitution, interpreting laws, and ensuring justice is accessible to all. The Supreme Court plays a pivotal role in the Indian judicial system and acts as a guardian of the Constitution.

🏛️ 1. Structure of the Supreme Court

A. Composition

  • Chief Justice of India (CJI): The head of the Supreme Court.

  • Other Judges: Initially, the Supreme Court had 8 other judges. This number has been increased to 33 judges (including the CJI) by the Supreme Court (Number of Judges) Act, 2019. The total strength can be increased by the President of India if required.

B. Appointment of Judges (Article 124)

  • Judges of the Supreme Court, including the Chief Justice, are appointed by the President of India.

  • The appointment process involves the recommendation of the collegium system, which is a body of senior judges, including the Chief Justice of India.

  • The collegium system was established by the Supreme Court’s ruling in 1993 (the Second Judges case) and was further refined in subsequent judgments.

  • Judges are appointed based on seniority, competence, and merit.

C. Retirement and Removal

  • Supreme Court judges retire at the age of 65 years.

  • They can only be removed by impeachment, which requires a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament.

⚖️ 2. Powers of the Supreme Court

A. Judicial Review

  • The Supreme Court has the power of judicial review, meaning it can review and declare unconstitutional any law or executive action that violates the Constitution.

  • This power ensures that the basic structure of the Constitution is protected, even if laws or executive orders violate it.

  • Judicial review acts as a check on legislative and executive actions, ensuring they are in conformity with the Constitution.

B. Original Jurisdiction (Article 131)

  • The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction in disputes between:

    1. Two or more states

    2. The Union and one or more states (except disputes involving the revenue of the Union)

  • This means the Supreme Court is the first court of hearing in such matters, and the cases go directly to it without being heard in any other court.

C. Appellate Jurisdiction

  • The Supreme Court has the appellate jurisdiction to hear appeals from:

    • High Courts on civil and criminal matters.

    • Any court or tribunal in the country where the case involves substantial questions of law regarding the interpretation of the Constitution.

  • It acts as the highest court of appeal in the country.

D. Advisory Jurisdiction (Article 143)

  • The President of India can refer certain questions of law or fact to the Supreme Court for an opinion.

  • The opinion given by the Supreme Court is advisory and not binding, but it holds great constitutional significance.

E. Power to Transfer Cases (Article 139A)

  • The Supreme Court has the power to transfer cases from one court or tribunal to another if it is satisfied that the matter requires the attention of the Supreme Court.

F. Contempt of Court (Article 129)

  • The Supreme Court has the power to punish for contempt of court. This power ensures that the authority and dignity of the court are maintained.

G. Review Powers (Article 137)

  • The Supreme Court has the authority to review its own judgments or orders, and it can modify or reverse its earlier decisions.

🧑‍⚖️ 3. Position of the Supreme Court in Indian Polity

A. Highest Judicial Authority

  • The Supreme Court is the final court of appeal in the country, and its decisions are binding on all other courts in India.

  • It is the guardian of the Constitution and has the authority to ensure the fundamental rights of citizens are protected.

B. Independent Judiciary

  • The independence of the judiciary is a cornerstone of the Indian Constitution. The Supreme Court is insulated from political influence, ensuring that it functions impartially and fairly.

  • Judges are appointed through the collegium system, and their security of tenure is provided by their retirement age and the stringent process of impeachment, which ensures judicial independence.

C. Guardian of the Constitution

  • The Supreme Court has a vital role in interpreting the Constitution. Through judicial review, it ensures that any law or executive action that violates the Constitution is struck down.

  • It has expanded the scope of fundamental rights and has played a key role in shaping the legal and political framework of India.

D. Instrument of Social Justice

  • Over the years, the Supreme Court has made numerous landmark judgments to promote social justice, ensuring that marginalized communities, such as Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, women, and minorities, receive equal protection under the law.

  • The Supreme Court’s role has evolved to promote social change, such as the recognition of Right to Privacy and Right to Education as part of Fundamental Rights.

E. Interpreting Fundamental Rights

  • The Supreme Court is a defender of fundamental rights, interpreting them expansively to adapt to modern needs.

  • It has also played a critical role in balancing individual rights against state interests (e.g., national security, public order).

❌ Criticisms and Challenges

A. Judicial Overreach

  • The Supreme Court has been accused of judicial overreach in certain cases, where its rulings have been perceived as encroaching upon the domains of the legislature or executive.

  • Critics argue that certain decisions of the Court have sometimes overstepped its judicial function, effectively making laws instead of interpreting them.

B. Delay in Justice

  • The Supreme Court is often criticized for the backlog of cases and the slow pace of justice delivery, leading to prolonged delays in the dispensation of justice.

  • The Court’s case load has grown significantly, but infrastructure constraints and the lack of sufficient judges have hampered its ability to handle cases in a timely manner.

C. Collegium System

  • The collegium system for appointing judges has faced criticism for lacking transparency and accountability. The absence of a clear selection process has raised concerns about favoritism and lack of merit-based appointments.

🧩 Conclusion

The Supreme Court of India is the ultimate judicial authority in the country, safeguarding the Constitution and fundamental rights of the people. It has the power of judicial review, the authority to interpret the Constitution, and the responsibility to ensure that laws are in harmony with constitutional principles.

Despite facing challenges such as judicial overreach, delays in justice, and issues with the collegium system, the Supreme Court plays an indispensable role in India's democratic framework, ensuring that the rule of law and the rights of citizens are upheld.


Tags:

Post a Comment

Please Select Embedded Mode To Show The Comment System.*

Previous Post Next Post
Share to other apps
Copy Post Link

Contact Form